DeSantis Replaces Campaign Manager in Major Shake-Up

In another effort to put his struggling campaign back on track, Ron DeSantis is replacing Generra Peck with James Uthmeier, one of the most trusted aides in the governor’s office.

Share full article
38

For weeks, Gov. Ron DeSantis of Florida has been making changes to his struggling presidential campaign.

Gov. Ron DeSantis of Florida has replaced his campaign manager, Generra Peck, in the latest shake-up in his weekslong attempt to reinvigorate his struggling bid for the White House.

Replacing Ms. Peck as campaign manager is James Uthmeier, the governor’s chief of staff and one of his most trusted advisers but someone with little campaign experience. In another significant shift, David Polyansky, one of the architects of the early-state strategy at Never Back Down, the main pro-DeSantis super PAC, is moving from that outside group to the campaign. The Messenger earlier reported the moves.

The campaign staffing changes — the third round in less than a month — come as Mr. DeSantis and his message have so far struggled to connect with Republican primary voters. Mr. DeSantis has built his candidacy on being a more electable Republican and the type of politician who can actually accomplish what he promises.

But a recent New York Times/Siena College poll showed that Republican voters viewed former President Donald J. Trump as a stronger candidate against President Biden in 2022, and as the Republican contender more likely to “get things done.”

Ms. Peck, who will stay on as the campaign’s chief strategist, had drawn heavy criticism from Mr. DeSantis’s allies and donors after heavy spending led to a fund-raising shortfall.

In response, the campaign had to lay off more than a third of its staff and start holding smaller events — a leaner operation more suited to a candidate who is trailing well behind Mr. Trump. Still, the successive rounds of changes have been an enduring distraction for Mr. DeSantis’s campaign.

In 2022, Ms. Peck, 36, oversaw Mr. DeSantis’s overwhelming re-election as governor, making herself an invaluable confidante to the governor and his wife, Casey. But she had never run a presidential campaign or worked on one. Mr. Uthmeier, 35, appears to have even less direct political experience than Ms. Peck, underscoring the degree to which Mr. DeSantis values personal loyalty and how the DeSantises’ trust often matters most.

Mr. Uthmeier, a member of the Federalist Society, the conservative legal group, served as general counsel to the governor and in the Trump administration. He began his career as a litigation associate in the Washington office of the firm Jones Day, according to the Federalist Society’s website.

“James Uthmeier has been one of Gov. DeSantis’s top advisers for years, and he is needed where it matters most: working hand in hand with Generra Peck and the rest of the team to put the governor in the best possible position to win this primary and defeat Joe Biden,” Andrew Romeo, the campaign’s communications director, said in a statement.

Mr. Uthmeier said in a statement that “people have written Governor DeSantis’s obituary many times” but that his boss “has proven that he knows how to win.”

The arrival of Mr. Polyansky, who has worked closely for years with the super PAC’s main strategist, Jeff Roe, is seen as an impactful change, as well. The super PAC and the campaign have had some tensions over strategy.

Mr. Polyansky has a precise understanding of politics in Iowa, where Mr. DeSantis’s fortunes increasingly ride on a strong showing. But Mr. Polyansky will also bring Mr. Roe’s thoughts about the campaign and its messaging directly into its top levels.

Under the current byzantine rules of campaign finance, strategists with the super PAC can join the campaign, but the reverse is prohibited.

Mr. Polyansky, who had been overseeing the super PAC’s early state operations, was on the trail in recent weeks with Mr. DeSantis as the group put together a bus tour for the governor. After the campaign’s cash crunch, the super PAC began taking over many of the functions normally associated with a campaign, like organizing retail stops and speaking events.

“David Polyansky will also be a critical addition to the team, given his presidential campaign experience in Iowa and work at Never Back Down,” Mr. Romeo said.

By the time Mr. DeSantis replaced her, Ms. Peck, who has limited strategic experience, was widely seen as miscast in the campaign manager role, even by those who liked her. She had come under fire for building a campaign team so quickly that Mr. DeSantis was forced to lay off roughly 40 percent of his aides only two months into his candidacy.

During a campaign retreat with donors in Park City, Utah, about two weeks ago, a few people raised concerns with Mr. DeSantis and his wife about the state of his campaign’s finances, according to three people briefed on the discussions.

The campaign’s finances were so worrying that Mr. Uthmeier, while still chief of staff, received a personal briefing on its finances from Ethan Eilon, now the deputy campaign manager, and then delivered an assessment to the governor.

Mr. Uthmeier has worked in the governor’s office since shortly after Mr. DeSantis took power in 2019. Since Mr. DeSantis announced his run for president, Mr. Uthmeier has sometimes worn two hats: In recent weeks, he also spent time raising money for the campaign. Mr. DeSantis has defended his aide’s actions, saying he was doing so as a volunteer.

Nikki Fried, the chairwoman of the Florida Democratic Party, filed ethics and election complaints against Mr. Uthmeier and two other top aides to Mr. DeSantis. She said the officials had illegally solicited contributions from lobbyists and endorsements from state lawmakers, who said they felt pressured into agreeing because Mr. DeSantis had yet to sign the state budget.

ImageJames Uthmeier previously served as general counsel to Mr. DeSantis and worked in the Trump administration.Credit…MA and F Collection 2018, via Alamy

Jonathan Swan contributed reporting from Washington.

Nicholas Nehamas is a campaign reporter, focusing on the candidacy of Gov. Ron DeSantis of Florida. Before joining The Times, he was an investigative reporter at the Miami Herald. More about Nicholas Nehamas

Shane Goldmacher is a national political reporter and was previously the chief political correspondent for the Metro desk. Before joining The Times, he worked at Politico, where he covered national Republican politics and the 2016 presidential campaign. More about Shane Goldmacher

Maggie Haberman is a senior political correspondent and the author of “Confidence Man: The Making of Donald Trump and the Breaking of America.” She was part of a team that won a Pulitzer Prize in 2018 for reporting on President Trump’s advisers and their connections to Russia. More about Maggie Haberman